Policy on Ground-Disturbing Activities and Cultural Resources
1.00 Purpose
The purpose of this policy is to establish a campus-wide framework governing ground-disturbing activities, whether resulting from intentional or unintentional actions, and to ensure compliance with applicable federal and state laws protecting Native American Human Remains, Cultural Items, and Tribal cultural resources.
This policy is also intended to prevent the unauthorized collection, acquisition, or retention of Native American Human Remains, Cultural Items, or other materials subject to NAGPRA or CalNAGPRA as a result of University-sponsored ground-disturbing activities.
This policy aligns with the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA), the California Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (CalNAGPRA), California Health and Safety Code §7050.5, Public Resources Code §5097.98, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and the CSUMB Master Plan Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program. It also aligns with the CSU Systemwide NAGPRA Policy as applicable to academic field schools and related instructional activities.
This policy ensures that all ground-disturbing activities conducted by or on behalf of Cal State Monterey Bay (CSUMB) are carried out in a manner that protects Native American Human Remains, Cultural Items and Tribal Cultural Resources.
This policy is deemed to be consistent with the University's commitment to the principles, goals, and ideals described in the CSUMB Founding Vision and its core values.
2.00 Scope
This policy applies to Ground-Disturbing Activities conducted by or under the sponsorship, supervision, operational control, or academic authority of the University, whether on or off campus. This includes field schools and research or instructional activities led, assisted, or supervised by CSU faculty or staff that meet the definition of Field Schools. Independent activities conducted solely under the authority of external organizations are excluded unless the University directs, sponsors, or otherwise exercises authority over the Ground-Disturbing Activity.
This policy applies to:
- All CSUMB faculty, staff, administrators, student employees, auxiliaries, contractors, and all visitors
- All University-owned, leased, or managed property including East Campus, limited to University-authorized activities such as construction, maintenance, utilities work, capital improvements, research activities, emergency repairs, and natural events such as storm damage, tree falls, erosion, or landslides that expose previously undisturbed ground; this policy does not apply to residents’ private living spaces or yards
- All CSU-sponsored academic field schools and research projects conducted on or off campus
Non-academic ground-disturbing activities include, but are not limited to:
- Construction and capital projects
- Facilities maintenance and repair
- Landscaping and irrigation installation
- Utility trenching
- Emergency repairs involving soil disturbance
- Natural disasters
- Campus events
- All other accidental and inadvertent discoveries
Research and course-related ground disturbing activities include but are not limited to:
- Academic excavation and field schools
- Planting or agricultural operations
- Environmental sampling or installation of field equipment
- Other research and instruction-related activities in which soil disturbance occurs
2.10 Clarification of Applicability
This policy is intended to provide a governance framework for activities that result in soil disturbance and does not prohibit or unduly restrict routine facilities work, academic instruction, research, agricultural work, internships, or student field experiences.
All activities meeting the definition of a Ground-Disturbing Activity are subject to pre-activity review as provided in this policy and its Procedural Guide. Review may be streamlined or programmatic for recurring or lower-risk activities, based on location, nature, depth, extent, and context of the proposed disturbance. Previous disturbance may inform the level of review, but does not automatically eliminate the review requirement.
The inclusion of contractors within the scope of this policy is intended to ensure consistent compliance with applicable law and is not intended to limit student research opportunities. Rather, it ensures that appropriate review and coordination occur when legally required.
Application of this policy shall be proportional to the activity and consistent with applicable federal and state law.
3.00 Definitions
This policy adopts the definitions of federal NAGPRA (25 U.S.C. §3001 and 43 C.F.R.10.2) and CalNAGPRA (CalNAGPRA §8012) as applicable. In cases where definitions differ, definitions are provided for clarification. This policy capitalizes "Tribe," "Tribal," and "Ancestor/s," except when quoting directly from the federal NAGPRA or CalNAGPRA statutes, where original capitalization is preserved.
Ancestor: Any physical part of the body of a Native American individual.
California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA): A California law requiring public agencies to evaluate and disclose the potential environmental impacts of proposed projects and to avoid or mitigate significant impacts where feasible, including impacts to historical resources, unique archaeological resources, and Tribal cultural resources.
California Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (CalNAGPRA): California law requiring state agencies and museums, including institutions receiving state funding, to identify Native American human remains and cultural items in their possession or control, consult with California Native American Tribes, and facilitate the repatriation of culturally affiliated human remains and cultural items in accordance with state law.
Consultation: The timely, formal, meaningful, and good-faith process of communication and interaction with Tribal Nations, Tribal governments, and lineal descendants that seeks, discusses, and considers their views, concerns, and recommendations prior to decisions affecting Native American human remains, cultural items, or Tribal cultural resources.
Cultural Affiliation: A relationship of shared group identity reasonably traceable historically or prehistorically between a present-day Indian Tribe and Human Remains or Cultural Items.
Cultural Items: As defined under federal NAGPRA 43 C.F.R. §10.2, means a funerary object, sacred object, or object of cultural patrimony according to the Native American traditional knowledge of a lineal descendant, Indian Tribe, or Native Hawaiian organization.
Field Schools: Any short-term academic program or course with a field work component that involves any ground-disturbing activity, led, assisted and/or supervised by CSU faculty or staff, that takes students or non-CSU affiliated individuals into the field to conduct research in a specific discipline (e.g., archaeology, geology, paleontology, environmental studies, marine biology, anthropology and geography).
Ground-Disturbing Activity: Any intentional or unintentional activity that results in the excavation, displacement, or exposure of soil or subsurface materials on University-owned, leased, or managed property, or that is conducted under the sponsorship, supervision, operational control, or academic authority of the University.
Hazardous Discoveries: The unexpected identification of potentially dangerous materials or conditions encountered during ground-disturbing activities, including but not limited to unexploded ordnance (UXO), munitions or explosive remnants, hazardous chemicals, biological agents, contaminated soils, or dangerous plant or animal hazards that may pose a risk to health, safety, or the environment.
Health and Safety Code §7050.5: A provision of California law requiring that, if human remains are discovered outside of a dedicated cemetery, all further excavation or disturbance of the site shall cease and the County Coroner shall be notified immediately. If the Coroner determines the remains are Native American, the Coroner must notify the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC), which will designate a Most Likely Descendant pursuant to Public Resources Code §5097.98 to make recommendations regarding treatment and disposition.
Human Remains: Any physical remains of a deceased individual, regardless of cultural affiliation or origin. In this procedural guide, the term “Ancestors” refers specifically to Native American human remains, while “human remains” may include both Native American and non-Native American remains.
Inadvertent Discovery: The unintentional uncovering of human remains, Cultural Items, archaeological resources, historical or colonial materials, military-related materials, or hazardous materials during ground-disturbing activity.
Most Likely Descendent (MLD): An individual identified by the Native American Heritage Commission pursuant to Public Resources Code §5097.98 as most likely to be culturally affiliated with Native American human remains discovered on non-federal land, and who has statutory authority to make recommendations regarding their treatment and disposition.
National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA): A federal law requiring federal agencies to evaluate the environmental impacts of proposed actions, including effects on cultural and historic resources, when a project involves federal funding, federal land, or federal approval.
Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA): Federal law applicable to federal agencies and to museums that receive federal funding and have possession or control of Native American Human Remains and cultural items to inventory such items, consult with lineal descendants and federally recognized Tribes, and, where appropriate, repatriate culturally affiliated human remains and cultural items in accordance with federal regulations.
Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC): The State of California agency that oversees the identification and protection of Native American cultural resources, designates Most Likely Descendants for discoveries on non-federal land, and administers CalNAGPRA compliance.
Pre-Activity Review: The initial review of a proposed Ground-Disturbing Activity conducted prior to the activity to determine whether additional cultural resource review, Tribal consultation, monitoring, mitigation, training, or other measures are required. The level of review shall be proportional to the nature, depth, location, extent, and context of the proposed activity and may include streamlined or programmatic review for recurring or lower-risk activities.
Public Resources Code §5097.98: California law governing the treatment and disposition of Native American Human Remains discovered on non-federal land, including notification to the Native American Heritage Commission, designation of a Most Likely Descendant, and consultation requirements regarding treatment and reburial.
4.00 Authority
Cal State Monterey Bay shall ensure that all ground-disturbing activities are conducted in compliance with applicable federal and state laws protecting Native American Human Remains, Cultural Items, and Tribal Cultural Resources.
The Cultural Heritage Office (CHO) shall oversee institutional NAGPRA and CalNAGPRA compliance, including coordination of consultation and repatriation associated with University collections and inadvertent discoveries. Departments and Colleges shall be responsible for coordinating project-specific Tribal consultation in accordance with applicable law, CSU policy, and University procedures/
The CHO shall implement appropriate review, consultation, and response processes to address inadvertent discoveries in accordance with NAGPRA, CalNAGPRA, Health and Safety Code §7050.5, and Public Resources Code §5097.98. Detailed operational procedures governing implementation of this policy shall be maintained separately and may be updated as necessary by the CHO in order to remain consistent with applicable law and CSU policy.
Compliance with this policy does not replace or supersede applicable federal or state environmental review requirements. Nothing in this policy supersedes statutory authority granted to the County Coroner, the Native American Heritage Commission, or Tribal representatives under applicable law.
5.00 Roles and Responsibilities
As indicated in section 2.10, all activities meeting the definition of ground-disturbing activities must consult with the Cultural Heritage Office and submit a Pre-Activity Review form. Submission timelines are specified in the Procedures guide.
5.10 Cultural Heritage Office
The Cultural Heritage Office serves as the central point of coordination for compliance and cultural sensitivity training under this policy.
5.20 Reporting and Stewardship of On-Campus Discoveries
Any human remains, Cultural Items, archaeological resources, historical or colonial materials, military-related materials, hazardous materials, or other potentially significant cultural resources (collectively referred to as “materials”) discovered during on-campus ground-disturbing activities, including routine instructional, research, agricultural, landscaping, or operational work, shall be reported immediately to the Cultural Heritage Office (CHO).
For activities not otherwise subject to CEQA, NEPA (where federal funding or federal approval triggers review), or other applicable environmental review processes, the CHO shall assess the discovery and determine appropriate actions consistent with applicable law and University stewardship responsibilities.
No materials shall be removed, altered, curated, or discarded without coordination with the Cultural Heritage Office and determination of applicable legal requirements.
Human Remains, Cultural Items, or materials that may be subject to NAGPRA or CalNAGPRA discovered during University-sponsored Ground-Disturbing Activities conducted off campus shall not be collected, removed from the discovery location, transported to the University, accepted into University custody, or retained for teaching, research, curation, or other purposes except as authorized by applicable law and in coordination with the Cultural Heritage Office. University employees and students shall immediately report such discoveries to the property owner or authorized property representative and the Cultural Heritage Office.
When a discovery occurs on property not owned, leased, or managed by the University, responsibility for complying with laws applicable to the property owner remains with the property owner. The University shall comply with its own legal and policy obligations and shall not assume possession or control of discovered materials solely as a result of University-sponsored activity occurring on the property.
5.30 Compensation for Tribal Consultation
The University requires compensation for Tribal participation in consultation processes in accordance with applicable procedures. The department or office overseeing a proposed ground-disturbing activity is responsible for funding the costs associated with Tribal consultation, Tribal monitoring, and other Tribal engagement activities related to projects or activities under their purview, in coordination with the Cultural Heritage Office and in accordance with applicable campus processes.
Such costs shall align with the University's established NAGPRA consultation fee structure, as outlined in the associated Procedural Guide. Costs associated with Tribal monitoring shall be the responsibility of the project sponsor and may include hourly rates, travel expenses, per diem, and other costs established through agreement with the Tribe.
5.40 Academic Field Schools
Field Schools, as defined by the CSU Systemwide NAGPRA Policy, including qualifying off-campus activities led, assisted, or supervised by CSU faculty or staff, shall comply with the systemwide policy, applicable law, and the University procedures in the associated Procedural Guide. The campus policy establishes local coordination and review responsibilities and does not replace systemwide requirements.
Field schools involving excavation or soil disturbance must:
- Be reviewed in advance by the Cultural Heritage Office;
- Ensure that the activity does not result in the unauthorized creation or retention of collections subject to NAGPRA or CalNAGPRA;
- Comply with all applicable permit requirements, landowner permissions, consultation obligations, discovery protocols, curation restrictions, and reporting requirements under the federal law, CA state law, CSU policy, and campus procedures; and
- Complete the required Tribal consultation in accordance with CSU Systemwide NAGPRA Policy.
Field activities that do not involve ground disturbance are outside the ground-disturbance review requirements of this section; other applicable CSU policies and legal obligations remain in effect.
5.50 Facilities Management Campus Planning & Development
Facilities Management Campus Planning & Development shall ensure that applicable cultural resource compliance measures are incorporated into construction and ground-disturbing projects.
Campus Planning & Development shall coordinate environmental review processes, including CEQA and NEPA where applicable, for capital projects, maintenance activities, and other ground-disturbing work under its jurisdiction, and ensure compliance with relevant federal and state laws and regulations.
Campus Planning & Development shall coordinate with the Cultural Heritage Office regarding all ground-disturbing activities under its purview, including coordination related to Native American cultural resources, consultation processes, and applicable legal requirements. This process includes coordination and establishment of practices for review of routine maintenance and day-to-day operational activities that involve ground disturbance. Information sharing shall be conducted in accordance with applicable legal requirements and Tribal consultation protocols.
5.60 Departments and Colleges
Departments and Colleges conducting excavation, field schools, subsurface research, or other activities involving ground disturbance shall coordinate with the Cultural Heritage Office prior to initiating such activities. The Cultural Heritage Office shall work with appropriate campus units to support compliance with this policy and applicable law.
5.70 Faculty
Faculty members overseeing University-sponsored ground-disturbing activities as described in section 2.10 shall ensure compliance with this policy and applicable laws. Faculty are responsible for ensuring compliance only for University-sponsored activities within the scope of this policy. Faculty are responsible for coordinating with the Cultural Heritage Office and submitting pre-activity review forms prior to initiating ground-disturbing activities and for ensuring that students and research personnel are instructed on reporting obligations related to inadvertent discoveries.
5.80 Students
Students engaged in academic coursework, research, field schools, or other activities involving ground disturbance shall comply with this policy and shall work under the supervision of faculty or authorized university personnel.
Students shall immediately report any inadvertent discovery to their supervising faculty member and the Cultural Heritage Office.
6.00 Continuous Renewal
This policy shall be reviewed ten years from its effective date to determine its utility and appropriateness. This policy may be reviewed before that time as necessary.
s/Interim President Carlos Vargas
Effective Date: November 13, 2026
Certification of Process
Review By: Cultural Heritage Office, Campus Planning & Development, Office of Community and Belonging, Administration & Finance, University Advancement, Student Affairs and Enrollment Management, Associated Students, Academic Affairs Leadership Team, Educational Planning and Policy Committee, Academic Senate.
Ground-Disturbing Activities and Cultural Resources
Procedural Guide
Purpose
The purpose of this Procedural Guide is to establish the operational steps and responsibilities necessary to implement the Ground-Disturbing Activities and Cultural Resources Policy.
This guide provides detailed procedures for responding to inadvertent discoveries of the unintentional uncovering of human remains, Cultural Items, archaeological resources, historical or colonial materials, military-related materials, or hazardous materials during ground-disturbing activities conducted by or on behalf of Cal State University, Monterey Bay (CSUMB).
These procedures are intended to ensure timely compliance with applicable federal and state law, including the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA), the California Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (CalNAGPRA), California Health and Safety Code §7050.5, Public Resources Code §5097.98, the CSU Systemwide NAGPRA Policy, and relevant campus requirements.
This document serves as an operational implementation guide and does not replace or supersede statutory requirements or University policy. Procedures may be updated as necessary to remain consistent with applicable law and CSU policy.
Definitions
This procedural guide adopts the definitions of federal NAGPRA (25 U.S.C. 3001 and 43 C.F.R. §10.2) and CalNAGPRA (CalNAGPRA §8012) as applicable. In cases where definitions differ, definitions are provided for clarification. This procedural guide capitalizes "Tribe," "Tribal," and "Ancestor/s," except when quoting directly from the federal NAGPRA or CalNAGPRA statutes, where original capitalization is preserved.
Ancestors: Any physical part of the body of a Native American individual.
California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA): A California law requiring public agencies to evaluate and disclose the potential environmental impacts of proposed projects and to avoid or mitigate significant impacts where feasible, including impacts to historical resources, unique archaeological resources, and Tribal cultural resources.
California Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (CalNAGPRA):
California law requiring state agencies and museums, including institutions receiving state funding, to identify Native American human remains and cultural items in their possession or control, consult with California Native American Tribes, and facilitate the repatriation of culturally affiliated human remains and cultural items in accordance with state law.
Consultation: The timely, formal, meaningful, and good-faith process of communication and interaction with Tribal Nations, Tribal governments, and lineal descendants that seeks, discusses, and considers their views, concerns, and recommendations prior to decisions affecting Native American human remains, cultural items, or Tribal cultural resources.
Cultural Affiliation: A relationship of shared group identity reasonably traceable historically or prehistorically between a present-day Indian Tribe and Human Remains or Cultural Items.
Cultural Items: As defined under federal NAGPRA 43 C.F.R. §10.2 and CalNAGPRA §8012(g). This guide capitalizes the term "cultural items" to indicate they are or potentially are of Native American origin. In cases where the term is lowercased in this policy, the text is from the federal NAGPRA or CalNAGPRA statutes.
Cultural Resource Management (CRM): Refers to the coordinated processes undertaken by the University to identify, evaluate, protect, and manage cultural resources in connection with planning, construction, maintenance, academic fieldwork, and other ground-disturbing activities, in compliance with applicable federal and state law, including NAGPRA, CalNAGPRA, CEQA, NEPA, and related statutes. CRM activities may be performed by qualified University employees or by contracted professionals retained to support compliance and resource protection.
Field Schools: Any short-term academic program or course with a field work component that involves any ground-disturbing activity, led, assisted and/or supervised by CSU faculty or staff, that takes students or non-CSU affiliated individuals into the field to conduct research in a specific discipline (e.g., archaeology, geology, paleontology, environmental studies, marine biology, anthropology and geography).
Ground-Disturbing Activity: Any intentional or unintentional activity that results in the excavation, displacement, or exposure of soil or subsurface materials on University-owned, leased, or managed property, or that is conducted under the sponsorship, supervision, operational control, or academic authority of the University.
Health and Safety Code §7050.5: A provision of California law requiring that, if human remains are discovered outside of a dedicated cemetery, all further excavation or disturbance of the site shall cease and the County Coroner shall be notified immediately. If the Coroner determines the remains are Native American, the Coroner must notify the Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC), which will designate a Most Likely Descendant pursuant to Public Resources Code §5097.98 to make recommendations regarding treatment and disposition.
Hazardous Discoveries: The unexpected identification of potentially dangerous materials or conditions encountered during ground-disturbing activities, including but not limited to unexploded ordnance (UXO), munitions or explosive remnants, hazardous chemicals, biological agents, contaminated soils, or dangerous plant or animal hazards that may pose a risk to health, safety, or the environment.
Human Remains: Any physical remains of a deceased individual, regardless of cultural affiliation or origin. In this procedural guide, the term “Ancestors” refers specifically to Native American human remains, while “human remains” may include both Native American and non-Native American remains.
Inadvertent Discovery: The unintentional uncovering of human remains, Cultural Items, archaeological resources, historical or colonial materials, military-related materials, or hazardous materials during ground-disturbing activity.
Most Likely Descendent (MLD): An individual identified by the Native American Heritage Commission pursuant to Public Resources Code §5097.98 as most likely to be culturally affiliated with Native American human remains discovered on non-federal land, and who has statutory authority to make recommendations regarding their treatment and disposition.
National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA): A federal law requiring federal agencies to evaluate the environmental impacts of proposed actions, including effects on cultural and historic resources, when a project involves federal funding, federal land, or federal approval.
Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act (NAGPRA): Federal law applicable to federal agencies and to museums that receive federal funding and have possession or control of Native American Human Remains and cultural items to inventory such items, consult with lineal descendants and federally recognized Tribes, and, where appropriate, repatriate culturally affiliated human remains and cultural items in accordance with federal regulations.
Native American Heritage Commission (NAHC): The State of California agency that oversees the identification and protection of Native American cultural resources, designates Most Likely Descendants for discoveries on non-federal land, and administers CalNAGPRA compliance.
Pre-Activity Review: The initial review of a proposed Ground-Disturbing Activity conducted prior to the activity to determine whether additional cultural resource review, Tribal consultation, monitoring, mitigation, training, or other measures are required. The level of review shall be proportional to the nature, depth, location, extent, and context of the proposed activity and may include streamlined or programmatic review for recurring or lower-risk activities.
Public Resources Code §5097.98: California law governing the treatment and disposition of Native American Human Remains discovered on non-federal land, including notification to the Native American Heritage Commission, designation of a Most Likely Descendant, and consultation requirements regarding treatment and reburial.
Site Archaeologist: A qualified professional who is typically contracted through a cultural resource management (CRM) firm retained by the project proponent (e.g., a developer, agency, or institution). The Site Archaeologist will either be, or be supervised by, an archaeologist who meets the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards for Archeology. They are responsible for conducting archaeological surveys, monitoring, documentation, and mitigation during ground-disturbing activities to ensure compliance with applicable laws such as CEQA, NEPA, Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), NAGPRA, and CalNAGPRA. The Site Archaeologist works in coordination with Tribal Monitors when Native American resources may be present.
Tribal Monitor: A representative designated by a California Indian Tribe traditionally and culturally affiliated with the geographic area of a project. Tribal Monitors can be present during ground-disturbing activities to observe, identify, and advocate for the protection of tribal cultural resources, Ancestral remains, and sacred items. Their presence ensures that Tribal Traditional Knowledge is meaningfully integrated into environmental and cultural resource compliance under laws such as NAGPRA, CalNAGPRA, AB 52, NEPA, Section 106 of the NHPA, and CEQA.
General Requirements
All ground-disturbing activities must comply with:
- Applicable federal and state law
- The CSU Systemwide NAGPRA Policy
- The CSUMB Master Plan Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP), where applicable
- Policy on Ground-Disturbing Activities and Cultural Resources
- Compliance with NEPA & CEQA requirements, including evaluation of historical resources, unique archaeological resources, and tribal cultural resources, when applicable.
Ground-disturbing activities may not proceed without review for potential cultural resource implications when required by this policy.
Pre-Activity Review
- Identify Activity: The responsible faculty, staff member, Department, College, or project lead shall identify proposed Ground-Disturbing Activities, including qualifying on- and off-campus Field Schools.
- Submit Review Form: The responsible unit shall submit Ground-Disturbing Activity Review Form to the Cultural Heritage Office in accordance with established timelines.
- Initial Review: The Cultural Heritage Office shall evaluate the proposed activity to identify applicable cultural resource requirements, including whether Tribal consultation, monitoring, or additional review may be required.
- Tribal Consultation: When required, the responsible Department or College shall coordinate and fund Tribal consultation in accordance with applicable law, CSU policy, and University procedures.
- Document Requirements: The Cultural Heritage Office shall provide written notification identifying applicable cultural resource requirements. The responsible Department or College shall document compliance with those requirements, including any Tribal consultation, monitoring, training, or mitigation.
- Authorization to Proceed: The responsible unit shall ensure that all applicable requirements have been satisfied and any necessary approvals obtained before beginning the activity.
Responsibilities During Pre-Activity Review
- Faculty, Staff, and Project Leads: Identify proposed activities, submit required documentation, coordinate with the Cultural Heritage Office, and ensure compliance with applicable conditions before work begins.
- Cultural Heritage Office: Conduct initial cultural resource review, identify applicable requirements for Tribal consultation, monitoring, training, or additional review, and provide written notification of review findings.
- Departments and Colleges: Coordinate and fund required Tribal consultation, Tribal monitoring, and other applicable compliance measures. Maintain documentation of consultation and ensure all requirements are satisfied before initiating activities.
- Campus Planning & Development: Coordinate applicable environmental review, construction-related requirements, and cultural resource compliance for activities under its jurisdiction.
Departments, Colleges, Campus Planning & Development, and other responsible units shall identify potential Ground-Disturbing Activity during project planning, course development, research approval, event planning, procurement, facilities work-order review, or other applicable administrative processes, and notify the Cultural Heritage Office.
Pre-Activity Review by the Cultural Heritage Office is required prior to initiating any activity that meets the definition of Ground-Disturbing Activity under the associated policy. Prior to initiating any ground-disturbing activities, the responsible department or college must submit the Ground-Disturbing Activity Review Form to the CHO at least six weeks prior to the planned activity. Activities planned for undisturbed soil or other situations that may require Tribal Consultation may have longer review times; consultation with the CHO should begin as soon as possible in the planning process.
Pre-activity review includes, as available, the project or activity description, location or map, anticipated depth and extent of soil disturbance, known previous disturbance, proposed start date and schedule, project contact, and any available plans, photographs, or supporting documentation.
Ground-disturbing activities conducted by University Corporation at East Campus shall be submitted through the established Facilities Management process. Facilities Management and/or Campus Planning & Development will coordinate with the Cultural Heritage Office, as applicable, to determine cultural resource compliance requirements.
During Pre-Activity Review, the Cultural Heritage Office may designate activities as routine or lower-risk based on the location, depth, extent, previous disturbance, and nature of the proposed work.
Although work within previously disturbed soil may qualify for streamlined review when the proposed disturbance remains within the known horizontal and vertical limits of previous disturbance, prior disturbance does not automatically constitute clearance, particularly when the extent or depth of previous disturbance is unknown.
In coordination with the Cultural Heritage Office and, where applicable, Campus Planning & Development, the following shall be evaluated:
- Whether the proposed activity is subject to review under NEPA or CEQA
- Whether archaeological sensitivity or Tribal cultural resource sensitivity exists at the project location
- Whether a Site Archaeologist and/or Tribal Monitor is required
- Whether Tribal consultation is required under applicable law or CSU policy
- Whether appropriate cultural resource compliance language, including mitigation and monitoring requirements, must be incorporated into contracts for external vendors or contractors
- Whether applicable requirements from the CSUMB Master Plan Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program (MMRP) apply
Upon completion of Pre-Activity Review, the Cultural Heritage Office shall provide written notification to the responsible unit identifying whether the proposed activity may proceed without additional cultural resource requirements or whether additional review, Tribal consultation, monitoring, mitigation, training, or other measures are required. The responsible unit shall document compliance with all applicable requirements before initiating the activity.
Departments and Colleges shall notify the Cultural Heritage Office as early as possible during project planning to determine compliance requirements, including responsibility for funding the costs associated with Tribal consultation or other Tribal engagement. For planned excavation, field schools, or large-scale ground-disturbing activities, advance coordination of approximately six months may be appropriate, depending on project scope and context.
The need for Tribal monitoring shall be determined through consultation with the appropriate Tribe(s). The responsible Department, College, or project sponsor shall coordinate and fund any required Tribal monitoring in accordance with applicable law, CSU policy, and University procedures.
For Field Schools, the University shall defer to consulting parties' recommendations when determining whether to approve or reject an application, in accordance with the CSU Systemwide NAGPRA Policy. If a consulting Tribe recommends that a proposed Field School not proceed, the application shall not be approved unless the concerns are addressed through further consultation and the applicable requirements are satisfied.
Review Process for Recurring Instructional and Research Activities
Recurring instructional or research activities involving substantially similar ground disturbance at the same locations may be reviewed on a programmatic basis. Faculty may submit a course, program, or research activity plan identifying the anticipated locations, methods, depth and extent of disturbance, equipment, and frequency of activity.
Following review, recurring university-sponsored activities conducted at the same locations using the same methods may receive cultural resource clearance for up to two years without requiring separate review each semester. A new review is required if the location, methods, depth, extent, or nature of the activity changes during the clearance period. Programmatic clearance does not supersede applicable Tribal consultation requirements, landowner permissions, or other obligations established by the CSU Systemwide NAGPRA Policy.
Important Notes
- Where Tribal consultation is required by law, project activities shall not proceed until consultation obligations have been satisfied in accordance with applicable legal requirements.
- For consultation conducted outside of statutory requirements, scheduling and timing shall be coordinated with the Cultural Heritage Office to ensure appropriate engagement while minimizing impacts to project timelines.
- Cultural Sensitivity Training will be provided by the Cultural Heritage Office, as applicable.
- Routine campus maintenance activities may be subject to modified coordination timelines, as determined in consultation with the Cultural Heritage Office based on the nature and context of the work.
Emergency Ground-Disturbing Activities
When immediate ground disturbance is necessary to address an imminent threat to health, safety, property, essential utilities, or University operations and advance coordination is not practicable, the responsible unit shall notify Facilities Management and the Cultural Heritage Office as soon as reasonably possible. Ground disturbance should be limited to the minimum area necessary to address the emergency.
All inadvertent discovery requirements remain in effect during emergency work.
Training
The University shall provide periodic Cultural Sensitivity Training to:
- Facilities and Operations personnel
- Project managers and contractors overseeing construction
- Students, Faculty and Staff conducting excavation or subsurface research
Training shall include awareness of inadvertent discovery procedures and reporting requirements.
Tribal Consultation
When the University engages in Tribal consultation under NAGPRA, CalNAGPRA, CEQA, NEPA, or other applicable legal or institutional processes, Tribal participation shall be compensated in accordance with University and CSU requirements.
Departments, Colleges, auxiliary organizations, contractors, and project sponsors shall be responsible for coordinating and funding required Tribal consultation and monitoring associated with activities under their purview. The Cultural Heritage Office shall identify applicable cultural resource compliance requirements and provide guidance regarding University procedures.
The University maintains an established consultation fee structure to support Tribal engagement. Departments and Colleges must confirm current rates with the Cultural Heritage Office during project planning.
Current Consultation Fee Structure
|
Item |
Rate |
|
Tribal Consultation Participation |
$250 per day, per Tribal representative |
|
Maximum Participants |
Up to four representatives per Tribe |
|
Typical Duration |
Up to two days |
|
Maximum Total |
Up to $2,000 per consultation event |
Note: This fee structure is subject to change. Consultation costs and applicable fee schedules will be reviewed during the Ground Disturbing Activity Review process and documented prior to approval.
Inadvertent Discoveries
In the event of any inadvertent discovery of human remains, Cultural Items, archaeological resources, historical or colonial materials, military-related materials, or hazardous materials during ground-disturbing activity, no materials shall be touched, moved, or disturbed, and the discovery shall be reported immediately in accordance with this guide.
Given the University’s history and site conditions, discoveries may include, but are not limited to, unexploded ordnance, munitions or explosive remnants, hazardous chemicals, biological agents, contaminated soils, or dangerous plant or animal hazards. These conditions may pose immediate risks to health and safety and require appropriate response and coordination.
Unexploded Ordinance Protocol
While the CSUMB campus is safe for routine campus activities, all ground disturbance should be considered a non-routine activity that requires review to determine the applicability of risk of unexploded ordinance or other concerns resulting from decades of prior military use.
A short training video has been produced by the Federal, State and local partners who helped during the closure of Fort Ord to safely transition the land responsibilities to entities such as CSUMB. This video is called the ‘Military Munitions Recognition and Safety Training’ and it should be watched prior to any ground disturbing activity in the former Fort Ord area. The video is available at fortordsafety.com.
All construction activity may be subject to additional training. Campus Planning & Development will determine if the proposed activity is considered construction and when additional training is appropriate.
On Campus Inadvertent Discovery of Human Remains and Cultural Items
Protocols for the Discovery of Human Remains
- Stop Work Immediately
- All further excavation or disturbance of the site shall cease and the area shall be secured.
- Do not touch anything.
- Immediately notify University Police to report the discovery. (831) 655-0268
- Immediately notify the site supervisor and Cultural Heritage Office to report the discovery. If applicable, contact the site archeologist and Tribal Monitor.
Jordan Leininger
Cultural Heritage Collections Manager & Repatriation Coordinator
Office: 831-582-3479
Cell: 559-360-4718
Email: jleininger@csumb.edu
- The County Coroner shall be notified in accordance with Health & Safety Code §7050.5.
- If the Coroner determines the remains are Native American, the Coroner shall notify the NAHC within 24 hours pursuant to Public Resources Code §5097.98.
- The NAHC shall identify an MLD.
- The Cultural Heritage Office shall coordinate in good faith with the NAHC and the MLD(s) regarding inspection, treatment, and disposition.
- Work shall not resume until authorized in writing by the appropriate legal authority.
NAHC’s Role
- NAHC designates an MLD from its official list.
- Priority:
- Tribes/individuals with documented ancestry to the area.
- Tribes within traditional cultural territory.
- Rotation system if multiple eligible.
- Once designated, the MLD is tied to the project until it concludes.
MLD Role
- Upon designation by the Native American Heritage Commission pursuant to Public Resources Code §5097.98, the Most Likely Descendant (MLD) shall be granted reasonable access to inspect the discovery site and the remains.
- The MLD shall make recommendations for treatment or disposition within 48 hours of access to the remains, as provided by law.
- The University shall make a good faith effort to reach agreement with the MLD regarding the appropriate treatment and disposition of the remains and any associated Cultural Items.
- Recommended treatment options under PRC §5097.98 may include:
- Preservation in place.
- Reburial of the remains in a location not subject to further disturbance.
- Scientific study, if agreed upon by the parties and consistent with applicable law.
- Other culturally appropriate treatment consistent with statutory requirements.
- If no agreement is reached, the matter may be referred to the NAHC for mediation as provided by law.
Protocols for the Discovery of Cultural Items
- All work within a minimum 100-foot radius shall immediately cease and the area shall be secured.
- Do not touch anything.
- Immediately notify the site supervisor and Cultural Heritage Office to report the discovery. If applicable, contact the site archeologist and Tribal Monitor.
Jordan Leininger, Cultural Heritage Collections Manager & Repatriation Coordinator
Office: 831-582-3479
Cell: 559-360-4718
Email: jleininger@csumb.edu
- The Cultural Heritage Office will take temporary protective custody of the items to prevent loss, theft, or damage, pending assessment and consultation under NAGPRA, CalNAGPRA, and applicable law.
- Documentation shall occur without alteration, cleaning, analysis, or public disclosure.
- Following initial assessment, the University shall initiate consultation and compliance procedures under NAGPRA and CalNAGPRA, as applicable.
Cultural Heritage Office and UPD’s Responsibilities
- Protect the site until consultation is complete.
- Discuss and confer with MLD in good faith about treatment options.
- If agreement is reached → implement the plan.
- If no agreement:
- Mediation may be requested via NAHC.
- If mediation fails, the landowner must rebury remains in a location not subject to further disturbance.
Mediation
- Either party may request NAHC mediation, but both must agree to participate.
NAGPRA
- The Cultural Heritage Office will initiate the NAGPRA process by:
- Updating inventories or summaries.
- Notifying federally recognized tribes with cultural affiliation.
- Consulting with tribes to determine repatriation or disposition
- Documenting and reporting disposition.
CalNAGPRA
- The Cultural Heritage Office will initiate the CalNAGPRA process by:
- Consulting with non-federally recognized California Indian tribes.
- Providing notice to the NAHC and culturally affiliated tribes.
- Coordinating repatriation or other disposition in accordance with tribal consultation outcomes.
Off Campus Inadvertent Discovery of Human Remains and Cultural Items
For University-sponsored activities conducted off campus, all ground-disturbing work in the discovery area shall cease immediately upon the discovery of potential human remains or cultural resources. The responsible faculty or staff member shall notify the appropriate local authorities, property owner or authorized representative, and the Cultural Heritage Office. Applicable notification, protection, consultation, and disposition requirements shall be followed in accordance with federal and state law and CSU policy. No discovered materials shall be collected, removed, or transported to the University without appropriate authorization.
Protocols for the Discovery of Archaeological or Historical Resources During CEQA-Regulated Activities
Stop Work Immediately
- No further disturbance within a 100-foot buffer.
- Do not touch anything.
- Demarcate buffer with stakes/flagging.
Notify
- Site Archaeologist
- Tribal Monitor (if applicable)
- Cultural Heritage Office
Discovery May Be Significant
- Site Archaeologist prepares research design/evaluation plan.
- Consult Tribe(s) if Native American in origin.
- Determine CEQA significance (Historical Resource / Unique Archaeological Resource).
If Determined Significant
- Preservation in place is preferred.
- If not feasible → data recovery plan.
- Maintain a buffer during implementation.
Site Archaeologist Responsibilities
- Technical analysis
- Written report
- Submit findings to Northwest Information Center (NWIC)
- Arrange permanent curation (if appropriate)
Master Plan MMRP Integration
Master Plan Mitigation Monitoring Requirements
- A Native American and archaeological monitor shall be present for earth disturbing work in native soils within 750 feet of a documented archaeological resource or tribal cultural resource, if such resources are discovered and documented in the future.
Contacts
Jordan Leininger
Cultural Heritage Collections Manager & Repatriation Coordinator
Office: (831) 582-3479
Cell: (559) 360-4718
Email: jleininger@csumb.edu
Website: csumb.edu/heritage
Nizhoni Chow-Garcia
AVP for Community and Belonging & Tribal Liaison
Office: (831) 582-3982
Email: nchow-garcia@csumb.edu
Website: csumb.edu/belonging
Matthew S. McCluney
Director of Campus Planning & Development
Planning Design & Construction
Office: (831) 582-4721
Email: mmccluney@csumb.edu
Website: csumb.edu/facilities/
UPD
(831) 655-0268
Resources
Laws, Policies, & Procedures
CalNAGPRA - CalNAGPRA 2001
CA AB 275 - CalNAGPRA AB-275 Native American cultural preservation (2019-2020)
CA AB 389 - CalNAGPRA AB-389 Native American repatriation: California Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act of 2001: California State University
California Health and Safety Code §7050.5 CSU Capital Planning, Design & Construction CSU Systemwide NAGPRA Policy
CSUMB Master Plan - Mitigation Monitoring and Reporting Program NAGPRA - 1990
Public Resources Code §5097.98
PRC §8012 - CA AB-978 Native American graves protection and repatriation (2001-2002)
Websites
CalNAGPRA - NAHC
CSU Office of Tribal Relations CSUMB Cultural Heritage Office NAGPRA